Skip to main content
Author(s):
Moritz Weiss
Journal
Informa UK Limited
Abstract

The increasing demand for cybersecurity has been met by a global supply, namely, a rapidly growing market of private companies that offer their services worldwide. Cybersecurity firms develop both defensive (e.g. protection of own networks) and offensive innovations (e.g. development of zero days), whereby they provide operational capacities and expertise to overstrained states. Yet, there is hardly any systematic knowledge of these new cybersecurity warriors to date. Who are they, and how can we differentiate them? This contribution to the special issue seeks to give an initial overview of the coordination between public and private actors in cyberspace. I thus explore these new private security forces by mapping the emerging market for these goods and services. The analysis develops a generic typology from a newly generated data set of almost one hundred companies. As a result of this stock-taking exercise, I suggest how to theorize public-private coordination as network relationships in order to provide a number of preliminary insights into the rise of this ‘brave new industry’ and to point out critical implications for the future of private security forces.

Concluding remarks
Most significantly, we need to find out the conditions under which firms are able to impose their will on governments. While concerns over the rise of a cyber-military-industrial complex may arguably be exaggerated, recent developments in cyberspace require further investigations. Historically, the MIC has been part of the rise of defence electronics and therefore of Silicon Valley. The latter was ultimately the Pentagon’s third-largest recipient county in the United States at the height of the Reagan build-up in the 1980s.Footnote84 Today, Silicon Valley is not only home to Google, Tesla and some of the most advanced defence electronics firms, but also of the many cybersecurity companies that operate from there. Between a number of these companies and the US government, there is an extensive exchange – not only of services, but also of personnel (i.e. revolving doors). These dynamics are similarly observable in the PMSCs market. Therefore, one might also argue that concerns over the rise of a MIC may even be an understatement. The reason is that we observe an evolution from cybersecurity firms helping the government to generate force towards the independent capacity of these firms to wage war more effectively than most states would be ever able to do.Footnote85 If this occurred and, then, drove public-private coordination in cyberspace, international security would be drastically transformed.

Reference details

DOI
10.1080/09592318.2021.1976574
Resource type
Journal Article
Year of Publication
2022
ISSN Number
0959-2318
Publication Area
Civilian cybersecurity
Date Published
2021-09-14

How to cite this reference:

Weiss, M. (2022). The rise of cybersecurity warriors? Informa UK Limited. https://doi.org/10.1080/09592318.2021.1976574 (Original work published)